Skip to content
OPENPROOFDEVELOPED BY TRUTHX
← Research and method
RESEARCH AND METHOD · 04

Three documents tell the same story.
How many sources do you really have?

“Who saw the truck arrive?” Your lawyer has three documents in front of her. The workshop report puts the delivery at 3:20 pm. The sales email gives the same time. So does the note to management. You thought the question of timing was settled.

01

Where did 3:20 pm come from?

You open the full email. The sales representative wrote “according to the workshop.” The note to management cites that email. For the delivery time, all three documents lead back to one report. Who in the workshop recorded 3:20 pm? That question is still open. The email and the note help you trace how the information travelled.

02

What the research shows

In 2009, Steven A. Greenberg followed a claim about a muscle disease through 242 publications and 675 citations. By tracing the citations back, he showed how papers had amplified the claim by repeating it without adding new data on the point in question. To find out what researchers had actually observed, he had to go back to the papers that reported the data.

03

Which document would you look for next?

Go back to the delivery. There may also be a delivery receipt showing 3:20 pm. Before you count a second source, ask who entered the time and where they got it. Someone on the loading dock may have noted it as the truck arrived. Someone may have copied it from the report. If you don’t know which, you know what to check next.

This is something we’re working on at OpenProof. You should be able to start with a claim, open the passage where it appears and trace it back to its source document. At your next meeting, you could tell your lawyer, “I found out where the sales representative got that time. Now I’m looking for the person who recorded it.”

Think back to the moment the sales representative answered the customer. Today you can see all three documents. That day, the representative had the workshop report. The management note that now seems to confirm the email was written after the reply.

What information did you have to go on when you made your decision that day?

YOUR NEXT STEP

Trace a source for yourself

During the trial, choose a time mentioned in two documents. Find the passage where it first appears. What would you check next?

Try OpenProof — 8 days free ↗

No card required. The trial currently runs in a test environment: fictional documents only.