A situation cannot fit in one record.
How do you document the context?
You have kept messages, emails and dates. Yet one question keeps returning when someone reads a single record: how do you explain what was happening around it? The challenge is to make the context open to examination while preserving what each source actually supports.
01
What one message leaves out
Take a fictional example. A message says: “Let me know before you go out.” Read alone, it might sound like an everyday arrangement. Understanding the situation also means asking whether the person could refuse, what happened when they did not reply and whether the request kept recurring.
You then find exchanges about cancelled appointments, spending that had to be explained and missed calls. These records invite you to examine their connections. Who is speaking? When? What is being reported, and by whom? A large number of messages does not, on its own, answer those questions.
02
Look at the person’s options over time
Evan Stark’s work on coercive control shifts attention towards conduct that restricts freedom over time. With Marianne Hester, he examines the relationship between control and violence and the challenges of measurement. Looking only at separate incidents risks leaving those restrictions out of view.
We take from this a question of method: what could the person still do at each stage? Work, see friends, use their money, leave? To document a change, you need the relevant records, their sequence and possible explanations. Similar events can belong to different contexts.
03
Living through something and making it understood
The philosopher Miranda Fricker distinguishes two forms of epistemic injustice. Prejudice can cause someone’s account to receive too little credibility. Gaps in shared interpretive resources can also unfairly disadvantage a person in understanding and expressing their experience. The difficulty then goes beyond how they tell their story.
For someone preparing a case, this raises an essential question: which words and connections help another person understand a situation they have not lived through? A request for detail may be necessary for review. It is more useful when it helps the search, rather than leaving someone alone with the task of explaining everything.
04
Reconstruct context from the available traces
Return to our example. An appointment was cancelled. A message received the evening before and a reply sent afterwards may help explain the sequence. The person’s account adds their experience of that moment. Another exchange may support a different reading. Each needs to keep its own place and source.
Documenting context means making these connections open to scrutiny: another person should be able to examine them. Separate what the records indicate, what people report and what you infer. Keep periods without records and questions still open visible.
05
What this requires of OpenProof
For you, and for the lawyer or professional taking over the case, the task goes beyond filing documents. You need to move from a question to the relevant passages, then see why events were connected, what other reading remains possible and what a new record changes.
This is the direction of our work on OpenProof: connecting analysis to sources, exploring possible sequences and enabling human review. An interpretation needs to remain open to revision and correction. Context can then become something people work on together, rather than depending entirely on the memory of the person telling the story.
06
A case file should also leave room for life
Rigour serves a human purpose: making work understandable and transferable, so someone does not have to carry the whole story alone at every meeting. It is also a question to ask of the product: does it help you move forward, or add another task to a life already occupied by the case?
The story “When a life has to become a case file” explores the other side of this requirement: lived time, which dates can organise without fully capturing, and the space you would like to recover for the rest of your life.
YOUR NEXT STEP
How would you like to pick up your case again?
Explore the OpenProof interface for eight days with fictional documents. Keep one question in mind: what would help you understand a situation and pass on your reading of it? Assess the approach before deciding what comes next.
Try OpenProof — 8 days free ↗No card required. The trial currently runs in a test environment: fictional documents only.
Already have an account? Sign in ↗
